Edo 2024: Supreme Court Must Prioritize Ballots Over Technicalities – Aiyevbekpen
As the Supreme Court prepares to deliver judgment on the appeal filed by the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) candidate, Asue Ighodalo, regarding the September 21, 2024 Edo State governorship election, political analyst Denis Aiyevbekpen has called on the apex court to prioritize justice over legal technicalities. In a statement released on Wednesday in Benin City, Aiyevbekpen urged the court to go beyond the rigid interpretations of the lower courts and engage the substance of the petition, which he said carries historical weight and democratic implications beyond mere legal formalities.
Aiyevbekpen argued that the matter before the Supreme Court should not be treated as a routine electoral challenge, but as a crucial test of the judiciary’s independence in politically sensitive cases. He noted that the lower courts had dismissed the PDP’s petition on procedural grounds, including the failure to call polling agents, despite documented irregularities in over 765 polling units. He emphasized that the alleged inconsistencies between the Bimodal Voter Accreditation System (BVAS) data and the announced results should not have been overlooked.
According to him, the PDP tendered 154 BVAS machines to support claims of result manipulation and mis-collation, yet these materials were dismissed by the Tribunal and Court of Appeal as “dumped documents” due to the absence of witnesses demonstrating each entry. He criticized the courts for choosing procedural convenience over verifiable digital records, insisting that such decisions undermine the purpose of the BVAS system and the intent of the Electoral Act.
The analyst highlighted a particularly grave allegation—the use of un-serialized ballot papers in violation of Section 73(2) of the Electoral Act—which he said creates room for ballot stuffing and multiple voting. He questioned whether the judiciary would allow such a serious breach to go unchallenged, stressing that failure to act would signify a missed opportunity to enforce electoral accountability.
Aiyevbekpen urged the Supreme Court to assert judicial courage over judicial convenience and to restore public confidence in the electoral process by upholding the principle that the will of the voters must not be overshadowed by technicalities. He warned that the failure of Nigeria’s judiciary to properly address electoral disputes has led to an alarming 88.9% failure rate of election petitions in the country, fostering a culture of electoral impunity.
The appeal, he said, is not merely about technical compliance but about protecting the sovereign mandate of the electorate. He argued that if the Supreme Court fails to intervene and reverse the injustice done by the lower courts, it risks further eroding the trust of Nigerians in both the judiciary and democratic institutions. Aiyevbekpen concluded by urging the judges to be guided by the spirit of the law, not just its letter, and to deliver a bold verdict that affirms the integrity of the electoral process and gives voice to the ballots of Edo people.

Comments
0 comments