NBA, ADC Clash As Lawyers Condemn Attacks On Justice Lifu

Published

The Nigerian Bar Association (NBA) has petitioned the Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Committee (LPDC) against lawyer Kalu Kalu over alleged derogatory comments directed at a Federal High Court judge, Justice Peter Lifu, following a controversial judgment involving the African Democratic Congress (ADC).

The development has triggered a fresh confrontation between the NBA and the opposition party, with the ADC accusing the lawyers’ association of taking sides in the country’s political crisis.

The controversy followed Justice Lifu’s November 5, 2026 judgment, which removed the national leadership of the ADC headed by former Senate President David Mark and invalidated decisions taken by the party under his leadership.

During a television interview on November 11, Kalu challenged interpretations of the judgment, particularly claims that the ruling had disqualified former Vice President Atiku Abubakar from contesting the 2027 presidential election.

The lawyer maintained that the judgment did not contain any pronouncement barring Atiku from participating in the forthcoming election.

However, his criticism attracted controversy after he referred to Justice Lifu as a “coconut judge”. When the interviewer cautioned him over the remark, Kalu reportedly withdrew the expression, stating, “Because of time, I do withdraw it.”

Reacting to the incident, NBA President, Oyinkansola Badejo-Okusanya (SAN), condemned the lawyer’s comments, describing personal attacks against judicial officers as unacceptable and inconsistent with the standards expected of legal practitioners.

In a statement issued on Friday, Badejo-Okusanya disclosed that she personally watched the interview and insisted that lawyers must maintain professional discipline, even when expressing strong disagreement with court decisions.

She acknowledged that legal practitioners have the right to examine judgments, challenge judicial reasoning and identify possible errors. However, she stressed that such criticism must be based on legal arguments rather than personal attacks against judges.

According to her, insulting judicial officers does not establish that their decisions are legally wrong or provide any meaningful remedy to parties dissatisfied with a judgment.

She further warned that such conduct undermines public debate and damages the reputation of the legal profession.

The NBA president also referenced the Rules of Professional Conduct for Legal Practitioners, 2023, which require lawyers to maintain high ethical standards and treat the courts with respect and dignity.

She explained that established procedures exist for raising complaints against judicial officers, adding that lawyers must use the appropriate channels rather than resorting to personal attacks.

The association subsequently forwarded a recording of Kalu’s television interview to the LPDC for consideration as part of its disciplinary petition.

However, the ADC has strongly criticised the NBA’s decision, accusing the association of applying its professional standards selectively and allowing itself to be drawn into the country’s political disputes.

In a statement issued by its National Publicity Secretary, Bolaji Abdullahi, the opposition party questioned why the NBA had not demonstrated similar concern over what it described as previous criticism of Justice Lifu by the Court of Appeal.

Abdullahi argued that the association should explain why it was pursuing disciplinary action against Kalu over comments that the party claimed were not significantly different from concerns previously raised about the judge.

While acknowledging the NBA’s historical contributions to democracy, the rule of law and the protection of judicial independence, the ADC warned against any perception that the association was aligning itself with the ruling party.

The opposition party also maintained that respect for the judiciary should not prevent lawyers from expressing concerns about judicial decisions or speaking against perceived injustice.

Although the ADC agreed that personal attacks against judges should not be encouraged, it accused the NBA of focusing on Kalu’s remarks while allegedly overlooking other issues capable of weakening public confidence in the judiciary.

The party described the disciplinary move as an attempt to intimidate a lawyer for expressing his political views and urged the association to demonstrate fairness and consistency in addressing matters concerning the legal profession.

The disagreement has further intensified the controversy surrounding Justice Lifu’s judgment on the ADC leadership, raising fresh questions about judicial independence, professional ethics and the role of lawyers in Nigeria’s political environment.

Author:
ireporteronline Staff

Comments

0 comments

    Join the discussion

    Use a display name or leave it blank to comment as Anonymous. Email is not required.