‘No Police, No Chaos’ Rivers Sets Bold Example For Nigeria’s On Election Day 

Despite the absence of police, the election was largely peaceful. Stakeholders are now debating whether the police should be replaced by civil defence personnel in future elections. Some argue that Nigeria’s democratic maturity warrants such a transition, while others warn that the country may not yet be ready for such a leap, given the high stakes of federal elections and the desperation of some politicians.

Conducting Elections Without Police Is Possible — Chief Edwin Clark
Chief Edwin Clark, convener of the Pan Niger Delta Forum (PANDEF), hailed the peaceful Rivers election, noting that it’s proof that Nigerians can manage their affairs without police intervention. He argued that the federal government and INEC should explore this development as a potential way to cut down on electoral costs and reduce violence.

Reviewing Police Involvement in Elections
Rev. Joseph Hayab, former Chairman of the Christian Association of Nigeria (CAN), noted that the Rivers election demonstrates Nigerians’ capacity for orderly conduct. He emphasized the need to reconsider the vast resources allocated to security during elections, especially when violence persists despite police presence.

Federal Elections Are Different — Barrister Obla
Barrister Obono Obla, a former Special Assistant to President Muhammadu Buhari, emphasized that comparing local elections with federal elections is misguided. He argued that high-stakes federal elections would descend into chaos without police presence, given the desperation of political actors.

A Necessary Evil?
Lawyer Amaebi Clarkson pointed out that while the Rivers election was peaceful, its stakes were lower. He believes police involvement remains necessary for maintaining order in elections with higher stakes, like gubernatorial and presidential contests.

Civil Defence as a Viable Alternative?
Prof. Gbade Ojo, a political scientist and former Chief of Staff to the Oyo State Government, suggested that civil defence personnel might be a less partisan alternative. However, their lack of experience and training in managing electoral security presents significant risks. A balanced approach utilizing both police and civil defence may be the best path forward.

Despite the success in Rivers, opinions remain divided on whether Nigeria is ready for elections without police intervention. For now, the police’s role remains essential, but the debate is far from over.